A first hip replacement consultation is more useful when you arrive with organised records, a precise account of your limitations, and questions that test whether the recommendation fits your body and goals. You will leave better prepared to understand the diagnosis, compare evidence, and make decisions about treatment, recovery, and risk.
Key takeaways
- Bring scan images, reports, medication lists, and a timeline of your symptoms.
- Ask how examination findings and scans confirm the hip as your pain source.
- Compare surgeons by training, experience, outcomes, and clear answers—not the word best.
- Match the recommendation with your health risks, mobility goals, support, and recovery plan.
Bring the Records and Symptom Details That Shape the Consultation
Take every record available to your hip replacement consultation, including the images themselves rather than only a written summary. At the appointment, the surgeon needs to match your symptoms with examination findings and scans; arthritis on an X-ray alone does not prove that hip replacement is the right treatment.
- Previous X-rays, MRI or CT scans, plus the radiology reports
- Blood-test results, especially recent tests related to anaemia, diabetes or kidney function
- A current medication list covering prescriptions, painkillers, vitamins and supplements
- An allergy list, including the reaction you had
- Your medical history, including previous operations, injections, major illnesses and hospital admissions
- A written symptom timeline showing when the pain began, how it changed and what treatments you have tried
| Symptom detail | What to describe |
|---|---|
| Pain location | Say whether it is in the groin, buttock, thigh or knee, and identify the worst area. |
| Walking | State how far you walk before stopping, whether you use a stick, and what makes you stop. |
| Stairs | Explain whether stairs cause pain, weakness or difficulty lifting the leg. |
| Sleep | Note whether pain wakes you, prevents turning, or requires medication. |
| Daily tasks | Mention problems putting on socks or shoes, getting into a car, standing, working or exercising. |
| Treatment response | Name physiotherapy, medicines, injections or activity changes you tried, and say how long relief lasted. |
Understand How the Surgeon Confirms the Pain Source and Treatment Need
A hip X-ray showing arthritis does not, by itself, prove that replacement is the answer. The surgeon must match the images with your symptoms, examination findings, walking ability and response to previous treatment, while checking whether pain comes from the hip, lumbar spine, sacroiliac joint or knee.
During the assessment, expect:
- A hip physical examination for tenderness, muscle strength, joint stability and pain triggered by specific movements.
- A gait assessment to identify limping, pelvic tilt, reduced stride or difficulty bearing weight.
- Hip range of motion testing, including flexion, extension, rotation, abduction and adduction.
- A leg-length comparison using examination landmarks, with imaging if the difference is uncertain.
- Questions about walking distance, stairs, sleep, work, footwear, and whether pain is in the groin, buttock, thigh or knee.
The recommendation usually follows this pattern:
| Option | What supports it | What it may involve |
|---|---|---|
| Non-surgical care | Symptoms remain manageable or treatment has not been fully tried | Physiotherapy, activity changes, medication, weight management or injection |
| Hip-preserving treatment | A specific problem affects a suitable joint before advanced arthritis | Treatment for impingement, a labral problem or selected structural deformity |
| Hip replacement | Persistent pain and functional loss despite non-surgical care, with matching joint damage | Replacing the damaged joint after discussing operative risks |
| More testing | Examination and images do not identify one clear pain source | Additional X-rays, MRI, blood tests, or assessment of the spine and sacroiliac joint |
Age alone should not decide the outcome; biological health, functional need and operative risk matter more.
Ask Specific Questions About the Operation, Implant, and Recovery
Ask the surgeon to connect each recommendation to your anatomy, bone quality, health and goals—not to a claim that one technique is best for everyone. The answers should also include evidence from joint registries or long-term follow-up and a plan if revision surgery becomes necessary.
- Why do you recommend an anterior, posterior or lateral approach for me, and what muscle, wound, nerve, dislocation or movement restrictions are most relevant in your practice?
- Which ceramic or metal femoral head and polyethylene or ceramic liner do you propose? What is their expected longevity, and what registry or follow-up evidence supports them?
- Why is cemented uncemented or hybrid fixation suitable for my age, bone quality and fracture risk? What happens if the fixation loosens?
- What pain relief is realistic, when should walking, sleeping, stairs and exercise improve, and which pain is unlikely to disappear?
- Will I bear full weight immediately, need a walker or crutches, attend physiotherapy, prevent blood clots, drive or return to work? Which symptoms require urgent contact?
| Choice | What to ask | What it reveals |
|---|---|---|
| Approach | Why this approach rather than the other two? | The trade-offs and restrictions your surgeon expects |
| Implant | Why this head-and-liner pairing for my activity and bone? | Whether durability and revision planning informed the choice |
| Fixation | Why cemented, uncemented or hybrid fixation? | Whether age, bone strength and fracture risk were considered |
| Recovery | What are my milestones and warning signs? | Whether transport, home help, stairs and follow-up are realistically planned |
Compare Surgeons Using Evidence Rather Than the Word Best
A “best” label tells you little. Compare the surgeon’s relevant case experience, the hospital’s safety results, and the service you will receive before and after surgery.
| Area | Evidence to request | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Surgeon | Number of primary and revision hip replacements performed recently; experience with your bone quality, diagnosis, and proposed fixation | Years in practice without procedure-specific figures |
| Safety | Surgeon’s or hospital’s complication reporting for infection, dislocation, blood clot, nerve injury, leg-length inequality, readmission, and revision | One generic success rate with no definitions or follow-up period |
| Facilities | Operating hospital, anaesthesia team, infection-prevention protocols, emergency support, blood bank, and physiotherapy arrangements | No clear answer about where complications are managed |
| Implant | Exact implant name, cemented, uncemented, or hybrid fixation, registry or follow-up evidence, and revision options | “This is the best implant” without patient-specific reasoning |
| Aftercare | Written schedule for wound checks, X-rays, walking progression, contact for urgent symptoms, and implant tracking and follow-up | Follow-up depends on finding help after discharge |
Ask whether the figures cover only primary operations and whether they come from an audited database. A national average cannot predict your risk because age, diabetes, smoking, previous surgery, and case complexity change outcomes.
UR Orthopaedic Clinic can be assessed by asking which hospital provides these facilities, who handles emergencies, and how your implant and follow-up records remain available if you need care elsewhere.
Related service
Total Hip Replacement At our orthopaedic clinic, we offer advanced Total Hip Replacement surgery for patients suffering from severe hip arthritis, joint damage, or chronic... View service → |
Check Whether the Recommendation Fits Your Risks, Goals, and Practical Plans
A recommendation fits when the expected improvement outweighs your surgical risks and matches your plans, not when you meet an age or BMI cutoff. Hip replacement eligibility depends on pain, stiffness, reduced function, failed non-surgical care, biological health and the source of pain—not an X-ray alone.
Ask the surgeon to explain these points:
- Age, bone quality and fixation: ask why cemented, uncemented or hybrid fixation suits your bone quality and fracture risk, and what evidence supports the implant’s longevity.
- Weight, smoking and diabetes risk: discuss wound problems, infection and revision risk, recent HbA1c results, smoking cessation and whether weight management could improve safety. No single BMI or HbA1c value decides every case.
- Previous surgery: report prior hip operations, hardware, infections and scars because they can change the surgical approach, blood loss and revision plan.
- Injections: give the date and type of every hip injection. A corticosteroid injection within three months of joint replacement has been linked with higher infection risk; your surgeon must set the waiting interval.
- Goals and support: state whether you want pain-free walking, stairs, sport or heavy work. Confirm who will help with meals, bathing, transport and exercises during the first weeks.
- Driving, work and exercise after surgery: obtain specific restrictions for your operation, vehicle, job demands and chosen activities. A desk job, manual work and impact sport require different return plans.
If risks are not controlled or support is unavailable, ask whether strengthening, medicines, walking aids or a delayed operation is safer.
Frequently asked questions
What should I bring to my first hip replacement consultation?
Bring your X-ray or MRI images, written reports, medication list, medical history, previous treatment details, and a timeline of symptoms.
How does a surgeon confirm that hip arthritis is causing my pain?
The surgeon matches your pain pattern with a physical examination and scan findings; arthritis on an X-ray alone does not establish the need for replacement.
What should I ask about hip replacement surgery and recovery?
Ask about the operation, implant type, expected benefits, risks, hospital stay, walking milestones, restrictions, physiotherapy, and signs of complications.
How can I compare hip replacement surgeons?
Check relevant orthopaedic training, hip replacement experience, complication and revision discussions, hospital facilities, and whether the surgeon explains alternatives clearly.
